… division of responsibility has settled which parts of the work each party answers for. Inside one part of a workspace, people still take part in different ways: some run it, some contribute, some review and some only read.
Problem
When access is set action by action for each person, nobody can read who plays which part, and every new member is a checklist. Named roles fix that, but no small, fixed set fits how every organisation divides its work. When no role fits, whoever manages the space gives a wider one for convenience. When the product lets them build roles from scratch instead, each exception gets a role of its own, and the list soon becomes as hard to read as access set person by person.
Solution
Offer a small set of stock roles named after the parts people play in the work. Let an organisation add a role only by copying a stock role and changing it, so every role keeps a named role it was made from. Describe each role in plain sentences of what it allows, and show on each role the people who hold it.
Continuation
Every person in the part holds a named role. Sharing gives one of them to each person it lets in, so the levels it offers are these roles. When an actor meets an action their role does not allow, explanation says which role allows it and who can give it, and unavailable actions hides only the actions that are not theirs to ask for. An outside agent holds a role as a person does, and what it may do there without asking is limited further by bounded autonomy. Permissions covers a different line, around what the artifact may reach on the actor's own device and accounts…
All connections
- Precedes
- Explanation, unavailable actions — When an actor meets an action their role does not allow, explanation says which role allows it and who can give it, and unavailable actions hides only the actions that are not theirs to ask for.
- Enables
- Division of responsibility — roles grade what each person may do inside the part their party answers for
- Enacts
- Agency — each person can see their role and what it allows them to do
- Complements
- Sharing — sharing gives each person it lets in one of the roles
- Related to
- Permissions — Permissions covers a different line, around what the artifact may reach on the actor's own device and accounts
- Workspace — Inside one part of a workspace, people still take part in different ways: some run it, some contribute, some review and some only read.
- Outside agent, bounded autonomy — An outside agent holds a role as a person does, and what it may do there without asking is limited further by bounded autonomy.
Resources & references
- Sandhu, Coyne, Feinstein & Youman (1996) Role-based access control models — rights attached to roles and roles to people, with role hierarchies and constraints
- Burghardt (2009) Working Through Screens, C5 “Permissions and views tailored to workers’ identities”, B7 “Object ownership and availability rules”
- GitHub: About custom repository roles — every custom role starts from a stock role and adds to it
- Choate. Roles and permissions redesign — copying an existing role and stock templates; assigned users shown on the role
- Figr. Permission management UI — grants readable as one sentence; templates against the pull toward broad roles
- Kosmalenar. Roles and permissions UX — role names that show their limits